Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login
A number of my watchers asked me to turn this journal into a news article:  

What I'd like to talk about is a trick that has helped me to become better at 2D art.  I'm sure many of you have heard that it's always better to draw from real life and from a model, and that tracing doesn't help you learn, but I don't know if anyone's ever explained why.  I don't think anyone has ever told me.  So I'm going to discuss how to make the best of different reference resources in order to get more out of drawing practice by thinking of your figure(s) in three dimensions.

When we make a drawing, painting, or any kind of 2D artwork, we're breaking down a 3D image onto a 2D plane.  Even cartoons are representing a 3D object; it's just been taken further from a realistic painting to its barest structure.  

This is an important thing to keep in mind while practicing drawing because it becomes a habit, especially for those people who like to draw cartoons, to think only 2D exclusively.  This is the easier, lazier way, but not the best way.  

Tracing and drawing from cartoon images will help a person learn to draw that specific 2D form, but will not help someone learn the 3D form that drawing is based on.  So when we take that picture of Simba we traced and try to draw it at even a slightly different angle, we've no idea how to do that.  

People say that drawing from life is the best thing you can do. That's absolutely true.  It's true not only because the nuances are there, the specific colors and details, but most importantly because it's already in 3D.  Our brains and eyes are constructed to think about that 3D form, even as we're drawing on a 2D surface.  So as we go over the contours and shapes of the body, we're actually committing to memory that 3D shape,  and we are becoming acquainted with and memorizing the figure (whatever that may be) as a real thing, rather than a particular pose or flat shape on the paper.  

But, as we are all very aware, we aren't able to get our hands on naked people whenever we like.  It's even harder to get live animal figures.  The best we can do is go to the zoo and hope the animals are out, close, and holding poses for us (not likely!), or go to a natural history museum (and that's helpful only if the taxidermy is very very good).  

So then our next best option (after anatomy books, which are only as good as the artist making them) is pictures. Here's the big problem. They're in 2D.  A 2D image of a 3D object, but still.  Our stereoscopic vision can't help us here. That runs us into trouble.  And that's where my advice comes in--to actively translate that photograph or video into 3D in your head before translating it back to 2D on your page.  

How to translate 3D from a 2D source:   

Anatomy books (and artist renders)--  Provided the artist is a good, accurate one, these are the best sources of 2D study.   Why?  Because the artist is (usually) purposefully pushing the 3D form in their drawing/painting.  They use their pencil or brush strokes to actually map out the shape of the form.  Most anatomy books go through the trouble to describe individual muscles and bones, too.  The next time you open an anatomy or art history book, compare the way in which the artists sculpt their work.  

Example:… at the way Leonardo Da Vinci handles his his pen strokes to show you the exact shape of the baby's limbs, trunk, and skull.  He's worked hard to describe the baby as a 3D form.  Imagine how much the image will have changed if the only marks were the contour of the body. In this self portrait by Rembrandt, see the way he describes the shape of the lips and his jaw with the pen marks.  

A lot of old etchings are excellent examples.  And what else?   The dollar!  (provided you live in America)  Get out a good old dollar bill and check out the freakin' amazing way old George's face has been sculpted with the lines. It's almost like a grid with the crosshatching.  

*If you're doing practice drawing, employing these same techniques is very useful in seeing and thinking in 3D.  Try to map out the shapes with a grid, and push the contour lines inside the form to describe the way it recedes into space.    There is a very good reason these hard-core artists did their sketches this way.  

Video--  The next best thing you can use is video.  Even if the video is a little blurry, you can still observe the shape moving, and by watching that movement, you can get a clearer idea of the 3D shape than in a purely 2D still image.   One of my favorite exercises for figures and especially expressions is to pop in a movie an freeze frame for quick drawing.

To really drill the form of the still frame, watch that little bit of video again  and again, and really observe the figure in action.  Then pause, and while you're working on your drawing, think about the 3D shape you constructed out of those moving images.   Videos are also fantastic for expressions.  People in videos make some very intriguing faces that you can capture more easily by freeze framing than by snapping photos.   They are also great for extreme poses.  Videos of the Olympics, action films, kung fu movies.  One of my personal favs is Shaolin Soccer.  And of course, all those PBS, Animal Planet, and National Geographic videos are great for animal figures.  And ideas for backgrounds and scenes, too, while you're at it.

Photographs:  These are the trickiest of the bunch,  especially blurry, small, poorly lit photographs.   If you are going to use photos to learn figurative form, try to find figures which have been well lit in a way that visually addresses the 3D form.

Compare the following photos:… is a really fun pose, but in terms of building a 3D shape, you'd already have to have drilled the human figure and know it pretty much by heart to flesh it out.  The folds in the clothing do a good job of describing the shape of the leg, but see how flat the forearms look.  It could be a great stock image for a lot of projects but isn't so useful for learning a figurative form.… and… look at these two.  The lighting more accurately describes the 3D form.  A person would learn more having rendered these two photographs than the above one, just by virtue of the difference in lighting.  

The most important part with any of these references is actually taking in and drilling the 3D shape in your brain while you're drawing.  Shade in a way that describes the form as 3D.  Try mapping out the figure's surface with a grid, just to notice and take in those little nuances on the surface.   Look at the way the masters did their pen work and etchings for examples of how to render a 2D form in 3D

Drawing like this is literally mentally exhausting.  But that's a good sign.   It means you're making your brain work.  Not only does this allow you to become beefed up in terms of your artistic library, but it's actually good for your brain, too.  Your brain, like your body, benefits from use.  Making your brain visually problem solve through grueling art drills will also make you better at creative problem solving and helps stave off mental diseases like Alzheimer's*

*this reported to me by my brother, who has been doing research in how brains work, brain training, etc.   

So next time you want to practice your human or animal figures and don't have a real 3D human or animal handy, try to think about your 2D reference as that 3D object while you work.  Not only will you learn better and faster, your finished drawings will begin to look more accurate and realistic.

Here are some more tips and tricks offered by my lovely watchers who too the time to pass on some information in my journal:

Working in sculpture and modeling is an amazing way to bone up on that 3D form and improve your drawing skills.  As with drawing, accurate and detailed reference is a must to best increase your visual library.

Take your sketchbook to a public place where people are going to be, like a coffee shop, beach, track meet, etc. to get some good figurative life drawing in.  Great for gestural work!

Using your own photographs are even better than using someone else's because you have stored away the memory of that 3D scene in your head.

A fun exercise to challenge your brain is to take your figure and turn it in space in your mind to draw it from a different angle.  This will really make you have to think hard about the dimensions in space.  

Establishing your perspective early and correctly will help place the figure and get you thinking about figure/ground interaction.

I hope this has been a useful read.  Now get out there and make some art!
Add a Comment:
rojus Featured By Owner Sep 1, 2013  Hobbyist General Artist
Please, check out also "FZD School of Design" you can find valuable insights on drawing and thinking in 3D from a professional concept artist.
Jay-Chan3 Featured By Owner Sep 1, 2009
This was a really refreshing read, you really gave me something to sleep on and absorb for the night before I pick up my sketchbook again tomorrow. That sort of brain training is really useful for physical skills as wel, such as martrial arts, sports, or even cooking... especially if you're learning from something like a video, or can't have someone else there to correct you all the time. I can imagine it'd be good for memory, too.

Another nifty trick I've found in this area is to use rendering software when models aren't available. A friend linked me to [link] awhile ago and it's refreshing and easy to incorperate into a daily routine... especially the 30 second gesture drawing application.

Awesome note, thanks again!
Vaxl Featured By Owner Jun 16, 2009  Student General Artist
What I hate is when I ask for help on something, and they tell me to get a glance of it in real life.

But I am not god, I can not summon forth mountains and waterfalls and forests.
The-Accursed-One Featured By Owner Jun 15, 2009
I'm going to come back to this later and finish reading it then because I strained my eyes earlier. They won't focus enough at the moment, but maybe after some rest.

From what I've read so far, I think it's going to lay some things out for me.
Nightshadow-t2 Featured By Owner May 31, 2009
Quite interesting. I especially love the resource material and I agree with the suggestions for going to the zoo, though in some cases a pet shop can help too. My main issue, though is that I have trouble visualizing the 2-D form. I can make the 3-D form, and while I mainly do dragons, I have done others. That part is fine. It's atempting to draw one that I end up agonizing over, especially if I'm trying to draw it before I've made the 3-D form. I can see the curves of the body, the scales and how they overlap, the hint of musculature beneath the scales in my head, and the lines of the wings, but it gets all twisted and confused when I try to put it on paper. And I think I went rather off-topic. Sorry about that.
smile-in-your-eyes Featured By Owner Apr 30, 2009
I can't tell you how amazing this all is, it helped me realize so much, and also explains why certain things were so hard to draw for me, especially if the models I were using weren't that accurate...

You know the movie "Spirit Stallion of the Cimarron" ?
MANY people were accused of tracing him, because he is extremely hard to draw. I soon came to the conclusion that maybey it was because he was animated as a 2d animal but was created using 3d technology...This just made me think of that...

Anyway, thanks for helping artists all over the world :D :D :D
ChiiKei Featured By Owner Apr 7, 2009  Hobbyist Digital Artist
This has helped me immensely! I've always had trouble visualizing in 3D, and the things you posted are great tips, I can't wait to try them out. Thank you ever so much! <3
lycaenops Featured By Owner Mar 27, 2009
Lulz, I'm paying my school a shit load of money for this kind of information. Thank you for sharing!
Koolstr Featured By Owner Mar 9, 2009  Hobbyist General Artist
This is amazing. Thanks so much, now I have the inspiration to practice! :D
twig7998 Featured By Owner Feb 10, 2009
Very handy article. :)
kazminya Featured By Owner Feb 9, 2009  Hobbyist General Artist
very enlightening, makes me want to try my hand at the drawing aspects again. Tried once, but hit the college to soon and with NO experience at all really. Discouraged I have not even looked back, but this is making me at least think about it. Perhaps I will.

Love your artworks to. See ya round deviant!. >^..^<
virtualzelia Featured By Owner Feb 5, 2009
What a great article. Thank you!
MuffinMachine Featured By Owner Feb 2, 2009
I find it's also very useful when looking at two dimensional images to close one eye. I picked this up after looking through a cardboard tube at the television set one time. The entire movie looked incredibly 3D without both eyes telling me it was just a flat surface of lights.
airyairy Featured By Owner Jan 27, 2009
Awesome article! I've really worried about my stuff looking flat, and I think this really helps!
D0RIAN0 Featured By Owner Jan 17, 2009  Professional General Artist
Nice article! I would say actual sculpting, traditional or digital, is by far the most effective way to improve your 3D thinking - after that I'd put "drawing through", where you indicate the form by drawing contours as though whatever you draw is slightly transparent
kanguruguru Featured By Owner Jan 16, 2009
Thanks for this. I wish my teachers had been as clear.
MrPlaid81 Featured By Owner Jan 7, 2009  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
A good reasoned argument for studying from reality. I'd like to see more solutions provided for the shut-in like me. Although using Google Video or Youtube to do figure study is the best answer I've come up with so far.
Neko-Kitty-Ninja Featured By Owner Jan 4, 2009  Hobbyist General Artist
I wish I didn't wait so long before I read this article o.o

really useful, and I'll definitely use it next time I draw

thanks for the info :heart:
Khanran Featured By Owner Jan 4, 2009  Student General Artist
Thank you so much! I've actually been thinking about this for a while now. It's really challenging.
baka-wallaby Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2009
*clappingclappingclapping* Cool.
Starbat Featured By Owner Dec 31, 2008  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Wow. I finally got around to reading this. I'm not a serious artist, but it's still a skill I'd like to develop on the side. The practical tips in this journal/new article will be quite useful I'm sure. Thanks so much for taking the time to share some of your professional artistic wisdome. :)
katarthis Featured By Owner Dec 31, 2008  Hobbyist Writer
I have to say this is the most informative how-to I believe I've ever read here. You gave a great explanation that no one else has ever given before, just as you pointed out.

May all artists find it profitable ... I know I did.

Dekker3D Featured By Owner Dec 28, 2008  Hobbyist Digital Artist
i may be very late with this, and someone may already have said it, but... teaching yourself how to use a 3d program, to a reasonable extent (being able to make most forms you see in 3d with the kind of quality you can be proud of... or the kind of quality that a fellow artist sees as reasonable) is a very good way to start thinking like that, since it's in itself an exercise in taking an object and memorising it in 3d. best thing is, you can't fool yourself by using tricks this way :)
tobymcwair Featured By Owner Dec 19, 2008  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Really useful, thanks a lot for the advises! I will try harder, and put them in practice as soon as i can.

"But, as we are all very aware, we aren't able to get our hands on naked people whenever we like." LOL to that phrase XD
Jianre-M Featured By Owner Dec 19, 2008  Professional Traditional Artist
If you have a 3-D program, messing with even a simple model in that is a really big help too! :D ("Poser" perhaps?)
Sobeita Featured By Owner Dec 19, 2008  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I completely agree with everything you said. I have a lot of trouble drawing from other drawings and paintings, simply because my perspective skews both the reference and my page. I have taken well to tablet art, but still find that my figures are often lopsided and misrepresented.
As far as good reference videos go, readers should try to draw both a stylized and an accurate still from the same pose in any video - sports shots are typically good for clothing and balance, but don't offer enough footage of the actual body. Try looking at slow-motion (high FPS) videos that show fluidity - you'll be surprised by what goes on in everyday life.
fangluva Featured By Owner Dec 19, 2008
I've wondered about this sort of thing a fair bit recently having done my once-in-a-blue-moon bit of drawing and wasn't very sure whether I was just thinking up crazy theories or if it was actually a good strategy. Hearing it from such an experienced artist is marvellous! I can now keep it in mind with confidence. =)
gangsta-dragon Featured By Owner Dec 19, 2008
wow, it's so true, but i've just never really thought about i that way. i think i'll start to conciously think in 3D when i draw now. very helpful.
RottoInk Featured By Owner Dec 18, 2008  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Very insightful. Really great article.
mianna Featured By Owner Dec 18, 2008  Professional General Artist
Making your brain visually problem solve through grueling art drills will also make you better at creative problem solving and helps stave off mental diseases like Alzheimer's*

That's nice to know 8D
MeiTaka Featured By Owner Dec 18, 2008
I've always heard about drawing from real life and not tracing and have told people who asked me for help with drawing but I could never really put it in such a thought provoking way that would help so much. Of course now that you put it into words it makes prefect sense. I realize over the years I've shaped the way I think when I draw into that way without really realizing it. I wish someone had told me this when I was young it would've made things so much easier. lol Thanks a lot for posting this and bring it to my attention so now I can share it with others. :)
4-X-S Featured By Owner Dec 18, 2008  Hobbyist Artist
There are mathematical model about the 3D vision that explains why things looks the way they are, part have to do with our universe (what is there to see) and part of it related to our eye (what can we see). I think its better to start from simple geometries such as a block, sphere, and polygon etc, and thinking analytically about there existence. A useful way to portray complex objects is to break it down to simple manageable geometric form that define the boundary of its existence, and then add on more features within the defined boundary.
enigmaticworld Featured By Owner May 29, 2010  Professional Artisan Crafter
Hm. That's some good idea. Do you have perhaps these mathematical models in some easy layman form somewhere on the web? I'm interested in further research :D
MacGuruX Featured By Owner Dec 18, 2008
Thanks for this great article!
sevenofeleven Featured By Owner Dec 18, 2008
Great article.

Since getting my hands on live naked people is kinda hard and expensive, I bought one of those Artist's drawing models.
Now I just need more time to draw.
BenRR Featured By Owner Dec 18, 2008
Wow! Great tips! I've been trying to figure out why I'm not improving very much, this might be the key. Thanks a lot!!! :dance:
SilverDog304 Featured By Owner Dec 18, 2008
Hmm, very interesting.....and I actually read it all, not often I take time to read that muchXD But this time it was interesting the whole time...
Think 3D...
Frankincensy Featured By Owner Dec 18, 2008  Student General Artist
This is great, thanks very much for taking the time to write and post it. :)
mertuygun Featured By Owner Dec 18, 2008
Thank you very much

AWdeV Featured By Owner Dec 18, 2008
"we aren't able to get our hands on naked people whenever we like"

Like fondling people, do you? :paranoid:

Anyway, great article. Very informative. :thumbsup::nod:
OliverMa Featured By Owner Dec 18, 2008  Student Interface Designer
i absolutely love this article :heart: it helped me heaps :D
scheppel Featured By Owner Dec 17, 2008   Digital Artist
Thank you for sharing
Vayde Featured By Owner Dec 17, 2008
Very informative =)
zarry Featured By Owner Dec 17, 2008  Professional Digital Artist
Great stuff. :) What you're talking about is one of the most valuable things that I leaned from art school. I still hate working from photographs, though, haha.

Another suggestion is to draw from sculpture. They're often lit nicely in galleries, and as long as you don't bring pens in, the guards will usually let you sketch to your hearts content. It's the next best thing to a nude model, and even if the sculpture is of some other subject, it's great practice in observing the directions planes are moving. It's also great for a more sustained sketch or study.

Thanks for the awesome post.
NizhoniWolf Featured By Owner Dec 17, 2008  Professional Traditional Artist
i really did enjoy reading this, and of course i found it very usful. thankyou for taking hetime to write this!
shadowleoparddreams Featured By Owner Dec 17, 2008
Wow, thanks. :D
jiggystardust Featured By Owner Dec 17, 2008
wolverine95 Featured By Owner Dec 17, 2008  Student
thank you very much, this was extremely useful!
Mysketchlog Featured By Owner Dec 17, 2008
Very awesome tips, will be sure to use them soon.
JazylH Featured By Owner Dec 17, 2008  Professional Filmographer
This was a great read & I totally agree with all your views. Tracing 2D helps at times but yes its not the Best way to do it. When ever I want a pose a usually look onto youtube & pose in front of the mirror camera at ready. I think its the best way to learn & you get to know alot of gripes that are involved with certain poses. Very interesting read again. :D
Add a Comment:

:iconhibbary: More from hibbary

Featured in Collections

Resources by KanaScott

More from DeviantArt


Submitted on
December 16, 2008


672 (who?)